For Celles sake…
You’re asking me to tell you to either dump one of my friends or an animal-loving recluse I’m not even sure I’ve ever met!
If I tell you to pick Star, then I’m the bad guy for being biased, nevermind that everypony adores Fluttershy. If I tell you to pick Fluttershy then I’m condemning my friend!
Pick whoever you love, but I have enough to worry about without getting dragged into this!