You lead Diamond Tiara to Aunt Bon-Bon’s room (because it’s not Lyra’s room). Immediately Diamond Tiara finds the whip laying on the floor. You couldn’t decide if you should take it or not and never put it back.

Diamond Tiara walks over and nudges the whip, “Nightmare Night was how long ago?”

You explain that it’s not a costume prop. That it’s a real leather whip.

She scoffs and picks up the whip, “Yeah, right. That’s not even possible. If this was real it would have to be ancient. They haven’t made…” She stops and looks at the whip closer, sliding her hoof across the whip’s braids. “What… is this made of? I’ve never seen this material before. This can’t really be…” She catches herself before she sounds too interested, “It’s still dumb, even if it is real. But I suppose I could gift it to Silver Spoon as a novelty.”

There is no way Aunt Bon-Bon would allow Diamond Tiara or Silver Spoon to have her whip. The moment she returns she’ll make them give it back. And when she does… Tartarus will look comfortable compared to what they’ll drag you through.

But… It would get them to leave you alone, for now at least. What choice do you have? It’s not like you could just invite them to go to another dimension with you for Silver Spoon’s birthday present.

What do you do?