Whatever you get, it ought the fit the requirements for any good present in that it is (a) expensive, (b) bought, and (c) not lovingly hand-crafted.

Anonymous
One outta three might be the best I can do. I’m not much for crafts, and I can’t afford expensive.
Have a batmitsvah. You'll get mad stacks.

Anonymous
Begrudgingly popular with the mysterious gentlecolt callers, I see. Why is it that I can't quite shake this feeling that struggling with my gift idea is something that will become common between nearly all of yourselves?
I hope you don’t begrudge me too much.
It might not be as bad for me. I’m not in a romantic relationship with my Bon-Bon. Some of the other Lyras might be freaking out, though.
Trying looking on uncommongoods to see if there's anything Bon-Bon would like on there.

Anonymous
I want to get her something useful and practical, not just random junk.
Though that Shower Squid might be nice.
…
Would the Tea Tower send the wrong message that I think she’s taking up too much counter-top space?
I know what you could get Bon-Bon. You could get Bon-Bon a babushka doll!

Anonymous
A nicknack? I’m sure she wouldn’t hate that, but I don’t know that she’d like it.
What are some of Bon-Bon's hobbies? Maybe get something related to one of those?

Anonymous
…
Well how am I supposed to know what she likes?!
It’s like not like we live together or anything!
…
I’m a horrible roommate…
What's the funniest joke you've ever heard?

Anonymous
Probably something vulgar I couldn’t repeat on my page.
Maybe something relating to mane and tail care? I'm sure keeping her mane and tail colors separated isn't exactly the easiest thing for her to do.

Anonymous

Anonymous
Somepony’s been around for a while. I’d forgotten that joke!
Bon-Bon's nickname is Bon-Bon Bondage, right? Just get her some new bondage gear. Or some new baking/cooking tools. Either would probably work.

Anonymous
You don’t get a housewife a new vacuum for Hearth’s Warming.
It needs to be something she’d use that isn’t related to work…
Completely ignoring that bit about gear, if you couldn’t tell.
What Did you get Bon-bon This Year?
Can you buy me the game Claus N Effect for Christmas?

Anonymous
If I could afford to buy somepony something for Hearth’s Warming, I’d have bought Boscov something.
Does Boscov ever inappropriately grope you or do other things to make you feel bad?

Anonymous
I- What- I don’t- Ugh…
Look, think of a gentlecolt. A gentlecolt at a fancy restaurant. That’s Boscov twenty-four/seven. He’s the nicest, kindest, most considerate… anything you’ll ever meet!
How do you feel about scary butt fun?

Anonymous
Sup' baby, seeing anyone currently?

Anonymous